Fly Fishing and Your Uncles, John

By Emma Arden

Maryland

On the western seaboard of the East Coast, a multimillionaire’s investment in one of Maryland’s “most charming small towns” has caused quite the splash. Described, once, by Frederick Douglass as “remarkable for nothing that I know of more than for the worn-out, sandy, desert-like appearance of its soil” and the “indigent and spiritless character of its inhabitants,” Easton, Maryland, has had a much needed facelift, under Paul Prager’s scalpel.

Paul Prager is no medical doctor. He’s a former U.S. Naval Officer turned Bitcoin mining mogul. In an interview with The Washingtonian, he described Easton’s facelift as “a reflection of [his] process: I start, then I get enthusiastic, then I get really enthusiastic, and then we get to the finished product.”

The finished product, so to speak, is a quaint New England-esque town with Chesapeake Bay charm, adorned with luxury coffee shops, boutiques, and French restaurants. Comprising a hefty real estate portfolio, Prager’s properties dominate nearly half of Easton’s main street.

Establishments that are more characteristic of Maryland, say fishing piers or golf courses, are outside of Paul Prager’s scope. This is, perhaps, due to his transplanted nature: “I grew up in Brooklyn,” he told The Washingtonian. “I don’t play golf.”

Regardless, if someone is building the dream, there must be those willing to buy it. Take my father, who purchased a four-bedroom, two-bathroom house in Easton, even though he was to move into the house alone. There is a simple lesson to be learned here, and that is if the buyer is sold, little else can be done to loosen that grip, that momentum on the so-called lead.

The first time I visited Easton was a year after my father moved. I was then nineteen, and it was summer. With little to do, I spent my time reading local newsletters, covering anything from boat insurance to sea glass.

I took particular interest in Rudow’s FishTalk Magazine. There was one article in which “Angler-in-Chief” Lenny Rudow gave readers the following advice on fly fishing: “First, use an intermediate line. Second, remember that bigger flies work better for the larger Bay predators. Third, have a rod with a sinking line with you, also (which allows you to fish down deeper.)” His advice seemed to promote a different kind of process to Paul Prager’s, one that held no promise of the finished product.

Lenny’s advice spurred somewhat of a fly fishing frenzy within me. Before this, fly fishing was nothing more than two words strung together by some flimsy thread. And beyond a casual reference to Norman MacLean, people by and large seemed to know little as well.

It turns out I was in the right place. Maryland, home to the U.S. National Aquarium, also happens to be home to the nation’s first state-wide fly fishing trail. The fly fishing trail divides the state in five regions: Western Maryland, the Capital Region, Southern Maryland, Central Maryland, and the Eastern Shore.

My father and I started for the closest trail to Easton, the Eastern Shore, heading for the aptly named Fishing Pier Road. When we arrived, however, Fishing Pier Road was not so much a pier as it was a two-thousand-foot-long dock sandwiched between the Choptank River and U.S. Route 50, permanently closed due to structural safety concerns.

We walked just off Fishing Pier Road and encountered a father and daughter duo who were fishing along the Choptank River. I asked them about fly fishing in the area, and the father said he didn’t know too much. He had just been a “casual angler” for the past forty years. “And not much changes,” he said. “When they bite, they bite.”

The casual angler did, however, allude to a time when Fishing Pier Road was bustling with fisherman and picnic-goers and everyone in between. Until a few years ago, he said the pier was the site of seasonal bass competitions– a phenomenon that all of Maryland is hooked on.

For instance, my father’s Easton realtor, Brian, placed in a competition along the four-point-three-mile Chesapeake Bay Bridge. “I was competing against sea captains and sailors,” Brian said, “and I still managed to place second.” Prize pools for such competitions can climb up to five million dollars.

After all, recreational fishing is a lucrative industry. Total annual expenditures are estimated between fifty and one-hundred billion dollars across the U.S., up to one-billion of which is spent on artificial fishing lures, flies, and soft plastics, alone. (Fly fishers can either purchase pre-made lures, craft lures of their own, but they hardly ever use real flies on a rod.)

Brian’s father-in-law is one such consumer. Brian took me to his in-law’s house to fish the Choptank River. We stocked up in their garage, equipped with enough supplies to run an Orvis storefront. His father-in-law estimates that he has spent hundreds of thousands on fishing gear alone. “You know,” he said, “I get a bit O-C-D about these things.

Along the Choptank River, our neon fishing lures glided under the surface of the water. After a while, I noticed that Brian held equal interest in fishing the Eastern Shore as he did selling it. His finger would point out the crabbing vessels and trotlines, and then slowly hover over plots of prime real estate. “You see that building?” Brian said, pointing to a mansion on the tip of the shoreline. “The ex-wife of the guy who owned MGM Grand lives there.”

We left empty-handed. Brian had caught one fish, but he determined it was sixteen inches long, and thus too small for Maryland’s catch-and-keep policy of nineteen to twenty-four inches that season. He released the fish back into the water and steered us to land.

Brian dropped me off in Easton, right next to the For Sale sign that signalled his and my father’s new deal. Although the excursion did little to aid my search for a fly fisher, I still thanked him. “Why of course, nothing wrong with helping good people,” Brian said, as he waved goodbye and drove away.

Fly fishing is quite different from regular old fishing, an old friend from school explained to me. “Fly fishing isn’t necessarily a more effective way of catching a fish, because now you have nets and modern rods and perfect lures and flies you can buy for thirty bucks,” my friend said. “But it’s kind of like a memory of the past.”

It seems as though my friend was not referring to personal memory, but a collective memory, a cultural institution that once was and now tries to emulate. “Before fly fishing, people would create rock pools or spearfish. But in order to get a fly that fish would bite, you had to study them. It’s like the art of doing anything, because there is always someone who will carry it on because of respect for how it is done.”

Fly fishing, then, becomes a question of who can access the art to carry it on, in the first place. “It’s not necessarily a cheap hobby. It’s not a technique for the village to catch fish. It’s an exclusive activity that only some are able to access. Like now, you can go on fly fishing retreats, like golfing.”

This old friend had been on such a retreat in Iceland, which marked his first and only time fly fishing. “That first trip I went on, I caught three or four fish– big ones, as well,” he said. “But, you are only allowed to keep the first ever fish you catch. They let you, as a fisherman, keep your first catch so there is no argument whether or not you were ever able to.”

Here, my friend is referring to maríulax, an Icelandic fishing tradition translating to Mary’s salmon, in reference to the Virgin Mary. “Every other fish, for the rest of my life, that I catch on that river, I have to put back.”

There are no trophies or badges, no daily catch to parade around. My old friend explained that with fly fishing, one constantly thinks about the why. “Fly fishing is about taking in what’s around you, focusing on your technique, thinking about the type of fly you're casting. For example, why you make lures green versus blue, because people know about fishes’ cornucopias, they study that.” He compared it to hunting hogs in the forest with spears. “But people don’t really hunt hogs with spears, because there’s not a lot of art to that,” he said.

Some would say my old friend represents a certain echelon of fly fishing. “If you think about the folks dressed in a certain way, with wax tops and high boots, that’s the English kelter of Maryland,” David Sikorski, a local Marylander and fly fisherman said to me, over the phone. “I see guys who wear LLBean, and I just have a pocket full of flies and my Crocs. I always joke that I’m a Polish fly fisherman– I’m really not that fancy.”

As the Executive Director of the Coastal Conservation Association of Maryland, David is “always trying to tell the big-picture story.” It is as if to say that fly fishing is a sport for the rich, but it is the fly fishermen who know the waters.

David finds entertainment in the public’s reaction to Norman MacLean’s A River Runs Through It, which popularised fly fishing in American culture. “It’s a technique that anyone can pick up, but it has a certain romanticism about it,” David said.

“But I’ve been locked into the idea of access,” he continued, “and many times, people can only access something they can walk or drive to, which can lead them to have different uses of the resource. This is what the godfather of fly fishing, Lefty Kreh, tried to break down.” He asked if I had heard of Lefty Kreh, and I hadn’t. “There’s a Maryland story with him,” David said.

Lefty Kreh was born in the Capital Region of Maryland, purchasing his first fly-rod outfit at Tochterman’s Fishing Tackle, fifty miles east of Baltimore. Not only did Lefty Kreh become good friends with the owner-and-operator duo of the tackle shop, but he invested in the larger Chesapeake community through the conservation of its local trout and marlin fisheries.

David said he had the pleasure of meeting the late Lefty Kreh before he passed, as did Andy Grosko, President of Free State Fly Fishers of Maryland. I had called Andy after finding his organisation under a list of Maryland fly fishing organisations along the Eastern Shore, in hopes of unravelling this Maryland story.

“I met Lefty Kreh, personally, a couple of times,” Andy said. “I met him, one time, at a library where he had a free session on fly fishing. At least five years later, I bumped into him in North Carolina in a fly fishing group. He just looks at me and says, Oh, Andy, how are you? just like that. He did a lot to promote fly fishing, and he was very much a down-to-earth guy.”

Andy said that Lefty Kreh became well-known by people all over the world, especially from wealthy countries, who would invite him to fish with kings and politicians. But Lefty Kreh had humble beginnings, writing an outdoors column for a local Maryland paper, The Frederick News-Post, and continued to publish all things fishing in The Baltimore Sun.

Rudow’s FishTalk Magazine covered Lefty Kreh in honour of his death in March 2018. The article included Lefty’s time as a forward artillery observer at the Battle of the Bulge, his survival of an anthrax infection during the Second World War and the subsequent naming of a substrain in honour of his initials, BVK-1, his profound legacy on fly fishing, and, equally that his most important lessons were not about fly fishing, at all.

It is people like David and Andy who keep this Maryland story alive. Despite being almost seventy years old, Andy teaches classes to help fellow fly fishers in his community. “I taught one of my last ones about aquatic entomology. You know, what bugs look like in different stages, how you key ‘em out.” Andy had gone to Penn State as a biology major, taking classes in anything from fishery to limnology.

“Somebody wrote an article when I was a teenager, at least fifty years ago, that said, Simplify Fishing,” Andy said. “The whole thing was that you don’t have to be able to cast well, you don’t have to cast far, you don’t have to be able to change flies a lot, but you have to pick a good spot. And look, you have to be a little bit persistent, but be in the right spot. And it's not that hard to be in the right spot.”

Andy used Rich Batiuk, one of the members of the Free State Fly Fishers of Maryland, as an example: “He said in a couple hours, he caught forty fish!” Rich Batiuk also helped design Maryland’s state-wide fly fishing trail, simply by charting where locals said they went fly fishing.

What I came to understand was that I simply hadn’t been to the right spot. I learned later on that the Eastern Shore had less to offer than its western counterpart. The strange thing was, I got the feeling that although I hadn’t caught anything, the fish, in the end, were besides the point.

“I just read one of the stories this morning,” Andy said, “about this guy who doesn't even talk about fishing when he talks about fishing. But he does it so subtly, that you don't realise until you're done– and he didn't catch any fish.”

My father sold his house soon after he bought it, with help from Brian on both sides of the deal. My father said if I was interested in fly fishing, best I reach out to his two uncles. So here’s a story, or technically two, about my great uncles who fly fish, both called John.

Uncle John Markle was taught to fly fish by a fishing guide, who happened to be his high school friend, on the Gunnison River in Colorado. Uncle John Markle became hooked, and years later, taught his friend how to fly fish. “Oddly enough, his name was also John, so let’s call him John D. to keep things straight,” his wife, Mary-Jane Markle, wrote to me.

“John M. loans John D. a pair of waders and a fly rod, and off they go to the river. John M. goes several yards downstream to fish, but after about five minutes, he sees John D. out of the river and back up on the bank. John M. walked over to ask what was wrong. John D.’s reply: ‘I didn’t catch anything. I’m done.’ It’s not a sport for everyone,” Aunt Mary-Jane wrote.

The other story has to do with Uncle John Greenlee, a Pennsylvania native who later moved to Maryland. “Western Maryland is better for fly fishing because of the mountain streams,” he said, a helpful piece of information only after the fact.

“I’m sixty-nine now, fishing for sixty-five of those,” Uncle John Greenlee said. “I fish with anything, and fly fishing is a whole different animal. With fly fishing, if you just take your fly, it’s a success. You’re just out there, in a stream, in your waders, using a fly to catch a ten-inch fish. And you don’t even care if you catch it or not.”

By the time I got around to reading A River Runs Through It and Other Stories, I preferred those other stories (especially one called Logging and Pimping and Your Pal, Jim.) Uncle John Greenlee said not to pay Norman MacLean too much attention, anyway, recommending another book that was “a little more about the relationship between people and fly fishing,” according to him. He was reluctant to expand, in case I were to one day read it. “But I’ll give you one thing,” he said, “there was a boy and a girl, and they were fly fishermen.”


THE HARVARD ADVOCATE
21 South Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
president@theharvardadvocate.com