Blackearth

By K.H. Ecker

Majdanek, the former extermination camp outside the Polish city of Lublin, is black, though none of its parts are. The long barracks, the few which still stand after a fire in 2010, are really a deep brown, wrought of a wood so dark it threatens to devour all the light around it. So too are the pyramidal guard towers, lining the main road of the camp, like gloomy, fuliginous sentries. At the end of the long road, or perhaps at the beginning, is the mausoleum: an enormous green dome, evoking a flying saucer, as though such a thing could come about only from the arrival of some mysterious and murderous extraterrestrial civilization. Emblazoned on its side in stark concrete lettering, in Polish:

LOS NASZ DLA WAS PRZESTROGĄ

— OUR FATE IS A WARNING TO YOU.

Beneath the dome is a vast mound of human ashes. The ashes are a sandy gray-brown in the afternoon light that streams down on them.

The gas chamber at Majdanek is one of the few left standing, owing to the Soviet army’s swift takeover of the camp, before the SS was able to demolish it. At Auschwitz-Birkenau the gas chambers and crematoria were dynamited as the Red Army approached. The inside of the gas chamber is stained a deep blue, in forms which slither and coil over its concrete walls. It is Prussian blue, the same pigment which gives Hokusai’s Great Wave its vibrance and sublimity. A compound formed by the reaction of Zyklon-B cyanide gas with the chamber’s surfaces. Blue blooms over the weighty room’s hard surfaces, slipping and creeping, an organism of clouds and tendrils, something gaseous in its own way. I am not afraid to say that it is beautiful, or at least, that in another time and place, in another universe, it could be. Prussian blue made Picasso’s Blue Period, and it made Majdanek, or Majdanek made it.

Even in blues we cannot escape Prussia: in the German tongue, in the Polish town. These German poetics of blue are incomplete without reference to the 1808 poem In lieblicher Bläue, by Friedrich Hölderlin, the German Romantic poet once described as “the most German of Germans.”

It begins:

In lieblicher Bläue blühet

mit dem metallenen Dache der Kirchthurm. Den umschwebet

Geschrei der Schwalben, den umgiebt die rührendste Bläue.

In lovely blue blooms

the church tower with its metal roof. There floats around it

the cry of swallows, encircled by the most poignant blueness.

It ends:

Leben ist Tod, und Tod ist auch ein Leben.

Life is death, and death is also a life.1

Hölderlin’s life and death, and his blue, ring hollow to me at Majdanek, though I had not yet read his poem when I was there. “How can the death that took place here,” I ask myself, I send myself back to ask myself, “be life? How can it be anything but simply death, less than death?”

The German phenomenologist philosopher Heidegger writes on Hölderlin’s poem in his 1951 lecture “Poetically Man Dwells”, developing the concept of “dwelling” central to his later thought, which he later described as “the essence of ‘being-in-the-world”. Heidegger writes, in his lecture on Hölderlin, “The radiance of [the sky’s] height is itself the darkness of its all-sheltering breadth. The blue of the sky's lovely blueness is the color of depth. The radiance of the sky is the dawn and dusk of the twilight, which shelters everything that can be proclaimed.” But the sky over Majdanek gives no shelter: it is merely, as Paul Celan puts it in his dark and resonant Todesfuge, “a grave in the air.” There is no church tower with a metal roof there, only the iron-reinforced brick smokestack of the crematorium. The blue of Majdanek has no depth, it is all surface, the incidental byproduct of a chemical reaction, nothing but a stain. I want to cry this out to Heidegger, who joined the Nazi Party in 1933, as I write myself into the empty gas chamber, and consider what might have been.

The brutal, surface-blue of Majdanek confronts the deep, dwelling blue of Hölderlin, and only one of the two can exist. German philosopher Theodor Adorno’s dictum, in his 1955 essay “On Cultural Criticism and Society”, that “[t]o write poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric,” has become well-known. Was it not barbaric before? Are we to believe that Auschwitz, or Majdanek, was some new invention in the history of human cruelty? Was it not merely an amplification of means? A prominent debate in German historiography in the postwar era, the so-called Historikerstreit, largely ended with philosopher and disciple of Adorno Jürgen Habermas’s argument that the Holocaust was entirely unique, incomparable to any other event. This argument may have been necessary then, but today it does not hold up. What Majdanek has to teach us can only be a lesson learned too late, one which the horrors of colonization or religious warfare or genocide did not move us enough to learn already. Hölderlin’s blue, the blue that shelters, the blue of dwelling, was not superseded when Zyklon-B cyanide gas oxidized to form stains of Prussian blue on the walls of a gas chamber. It simply never existed—and if we have only learned so now, we have done so too late. What Majdanek has to tell me about death is its absolute emptiness, the nothingness of a stain on a concrete wall, the void of a gray sky over the small Polish city of Lublin.

Only the crows which circle around the smokestack and the cloudless sky are truly black. Their foreboding caws lend a certain groundedness to the scene; it is strange how much the place feels like it belongs. The barracks and the guard towers and the mausoleum and the crematorium and the crows come together to form a perfect unity, a place which feels like it climbed out of the earth one day ready-made, some chthonic deity.

Though none of its elements are exactly black, blackness is the characteristic of Majdanek. It sucks light greedily from the air as though it belonged more than the light did, as though the sun were begrudgingly granted to shine down upon Majdanek only so that its darkness would be better distinguished.

It is the color of Celan’s brief poem Schwarzerde:

Schwarzerde, schwarze

Erde du, Stunden-

mutter

Verzweiflung:

Ein aus der Hand und ihrer

Wunde dir Zu-

geborenes schließt

deine Kelche.


Blackearth, black

earth, you, hour-

mother

Despair:

Something born you-ward

from the hand and its

wounds, shuts

your calyces.

For Celan, poet and Holocaust survivor, whose career stretched from his native Czernowitz, Romania to the postwar Paris where he wrote, the earth is something which combines birth and death. It is black earth which is the most fertile soil, the hour-mother which brings about time and life. But as the earth gives, it also receives—“Something born you-ward / from the hand and its / wounds” is already being sent back to the earth at the moment of its birth. It shuts the calyces (the German word also means “chalices”): shutting the earth off, closing the sources of its liquid bounty, sending it into a state of vegetable self-protection.

Celan’s black earth is that of the fields of his native Romania, the mother-earth-goddess of growth and birth, and it is the black earth of grave-dirt, and the two are the same. Actually, the earth around Majdanek does not appear black, it was verdantly green when I saw it in the spring. Surely, though, its color is held up by the blackness of fresh soil, through which move worms that eat into the wooden structures and will one day reduce Majdanek to dust. As I walked around the wooden buildings, the scents of timber and age were mixed with the fresh smell of new grass.

***

You have probably guessed that I am Jewish, if only because to write about such things otherwise would be to be bolder than I am. It is strange, though perhaps not so strange, that writing about the Holocaust demands writing about one’s self. It is an event, one of many, which refuses to be read disinterestedly, which strikes back with grandfathers and grandmothers and and great-uncles and great-aunts and second cousins twice removed at him who might try to keep his distance from it.

My grandmother was born in Elbing, East Prussia, in December 1926. This year she will turn 100, we hope. She did not spend time in the camps, though my grandfather did: he was interned at Buchenwald and eventually liberated from the Dachau camp by the U.S. army in April 1945. I never knew my grandfather; in fact, he died before my mother was born in 1963, at the age of 41. My grandmother, who escaped Germany with her family shortly after Kristallnacht in 1937, spent the war seeking asylum in the Philippines. She was treated with relative leniency there by the otherwise brutal Japanese occupiers, who assumed because of their papers that her family was of a friendly nation.

I feel a certain distaste recounting these details to you, as though I myself have to show my papers before I may cross the border. In earlier times, I have felt that the sufferings of my elder relatives were a validation of my otherwise shaky Judaism. I was once, in showing photos of my grandfather’s concentration camp papers to a fellow Jewish kid at summer camp out of a desire to prove something, tersely and memorably rebuked: Don’t you realize we all have those?

Today, I feel discomfort with an identity rooted in the validity of suffering, and don’t believe that my identity has to be so. This is not a story about grandmothers or grandfathers; many such stories have been told already, and I am not the one to tell them.

Yet this story has been told already, too. The experience of visiting a concentration camp is not unique. Every year, about 2 million people visit Auschwitz, about as many as visit Washington, D.C., Boston, or Chicago annually. I went to Majdanek on a high school trip to Holocaust sites across Central and Eastern Europe, along with a couple dozen of my classmates and teachers. Though Majdanek is generally off the beaten path, quite empty when we visited, on most of our visits we encountered many other groups with the same intentions as us.

In the spring of 2023, I remember some of my (non-Jewish) classmates claiming to see fingernail scratches on the walls of the gas chamber. I find this distasteful, as though one needed to search for the minute details of suffering when the totality of it was right in front of us, as though the lurid details might somehow make the whole thing finally come true. Yet at the same time I understand the feeling and the inclination: that there is something about seeing sites of the Holocaust today that feels profoundly unreal, that there is an irresolvable distance between their time and ours. I understand the desire to bridge this gap by seeking what is inscribed in the most human of traces, even if I disagree with the impulse toward sensationalism. It is difficult to sit in the café at Auschwitz and feel that one has understood, or can understand, Auschwitz.

***

Auschwitz is not black, it is red. All bricks and red-tiled roofs, it feels sturdier and more man-made than Majdanek. There is nothing particularly mythic about it; the whole thing is a testament to human industrial capabilities.

What is most striking about the camp is its scale. The camp is actually divided into several camps: Auschwitz I, Auschwitz II–Birkenau, and Auschwitz III–Monowitz. Auschwitz I is mostly a museum, and home to the infamous “Arbeit macht frei” gate. Auschwitz II (Birkenau) was home to the camp’s extermination center, and it is here that the camp’s size is truly unsettling. The road in Birkenau which passes through the matrix of camp buildings feels unending; the number of buildings, including those in ruins due to their demolition by the SS, makes the whole site feel like an abandoned ghost town. I cannot help but feel small, even immaterial there, walking through the massive grid of ruined brick buildings, like the optical illusion of a grid where circles appear at the intersections, disappearing as soon as we look for them, endlessly out of reach.

Today, there is laughter buried at Auschwitz, or built upon it. It’s hidden even in the word—“Witz” is German for “joke.” As we walk past the train tracks and the brick barracks I stumble over it, or hit my head on it, a laughter which swoops on me like a crazed animal and refuses to let me go. There is a kind of absurdity in what we are doing, as though we could ever access some kind of truth by walking through the ruins of a concentration camp in the rain for half an hour. It is absurd that anyone is allowed to be here, and that their presence requires all of the requirements that human beings require.

There is a cafe at Auschwitz, and they serve dessert. There is something sickening about chocolate cake at Auschwitz, but I choose to eat it. It seems like the food there should taste bad, but it doesn’t. A part of me thinks it should be cooked with the lowest possible level of effort, spat in by the wait staff and served to us cold. As though cold food could get us any closer to the truth of human suffering. Since eating at all, and especially eating dessert, already feels wrong, I start thinking of foods that would be the most inappropriate to serve at a concentration camp café.

Cook-it-yourself hot pot. A revolving sushi bar. A chocolate fountain.

I start to put myself into hysterics, and this is bad because I am at Auschwitz, and laughing as one walks around Auschwitz is not exactly socially acceptable behavior. I notice, however, that I am not the only one with a certain absence of decorum. The walls inside the accessible Auschwitz buildings, and surely some of the non-accessible ones too, are spotted with scratches and graffiti, presumably done out of the same set of mostly stupid reasons that one puts graffiti on anything. In the best case, a desire for permanence: a hope that one could somehow inscribe oneself onto History and live on, dragged remorselessly in its wake.

Some visitors pose for photos in front of the main gate, grinning widely, draped in Israeli flags. They are on the March of the Living, an annual event which sends Jewish students and adults from across the world on a march from Auschwitz to Birkenau, and then flies them to Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. The March of the Living is meant to create a connection between the living and the dead, and the living Jews and each other. Yet it does so under the banner of a state which does not speak for all Jews, living or dead, whose presumptions to speak for the whole render it untrustworthy. As a Jew today it is difficult for me to feel that our “people”, whoever they might be, is not more in the place of oppressor than survivor. I doubt whether many of the blue-and-white-draped visitors see any reflection of Gaza (which was a prison long before October 7th) in the long rows and columns of barracks, the barbed wire and guard towers. Most of the liberal Jews on my trip do not trust these marchers: we feel that there is some great difference between us, and that what is our memory from Auschwitz will not be theirs.

As we walk through the steadily-growing rain and mud, a boy of about fourteen from a UK March of the Living delegation begins to urinate in a pond in front of us, a pond which contains the ashes of many tens of thousands of those murdered at the camp. My group and I are horrified. Yet as I think back to my horror, I wonder more about what it implies. I am reminded of the line from Psalm 8:4, rendered in the King James Version: “What is man, that thou art mindful of him?”

What is Auschwitz, that we are mindful of it?

Is it a holy place?

A tomb?

A museum?

A temple?

A monument?

A theme park?

An example?

A piece of evidence?

A figure of speech?

A warning?

What would a civilization thousands, hundreds of thousands of years from now think of this place, if there is anything left of it to encounter, or anyone left to encounter it? I consider the messages devised for long-term nuclear waste repositories:

This place is not a place of honor…no highly esteemed deed is commemorated here…nothing valued is here.

What is here was dangerous and repulsive to us. This message is a warning about danger.

The danger is still present in your time, as it was in ours.

1 Translations mine.

2 Pierre Joris’s admirable translation.

3 The recent film A Real Pain, however, directed by and starring Jesse Eisenberg and Kieran Culkin, depicts such a visit and speaks to the present significance of Holocaust tourism, perhaps growing as the last survivors dwindle.

THE HARVARD ADVOCATE
21 South Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
president@theharvardadvocate.com