Notes

Notes from Middle School

By Anna Popnikolova

Trying to amuse myself while home for the summer, I decided to take a few shifts as a substitute teacher. I’ve never been passionate about education, but it seemed as good a way to kill time as any. By the hand of some cruel substitute-teacher-sorting god, I was placed in middle school. I consoled myself: it would be less sentimental than elementary or high school would have been (after public elementary, I attended, for some reason, a private middle school. I then returned to the public high school after I was rejected from Andover), so at least I wouldn’t be crying on the clock. Yes, even though middle school is notoriously one of the worst things ever, I would approach the situation with a cool air of indifference. I would have rather not gone back to the old house. At least not my old house. This was someone else’s old house with someone else’s skeletons in the janitor’s closet. I got to walk through those foreign hallowed halls for the first time, my temporary badge pasted precariously to my shirt. Yes, it read ‘VISITOR.’ I was given what is, in one’s hometown, the rare blessing of novelty.

On the first day, I developed a migraine so terrible that I thought I’d end up like the woman from City of the Living Dead, crying tears of blood in the gender neutral staff bathroom. My only form of entertainment was my journal, where I spent all day painstakingly detailing the behaviors of middle school boys. I came to the ultimate, unsurprising, realization that all boys in the world exhibit these same behaviors (albeit in slightly varied forms, usually attributed to either to “personality”, perhaps mothering,  depending on which psychoanalysts you subscribe to). This recurs ad infinitum for the rest of our stupid boring lives.

To make my second day less painful, I bring a copy of Elif Batuman’s second piece of autofiction, Either/Or, a continuation of her first, The Idiot. In both of these books, Batuman provides first-person accounts of her first two years at Harvard, where she studied very similar subjects to me and also lived in Mather House. I enjoy her writing, even though we are quite similar and seem to become more similar the more I read. This too, is painful. I keep treading the roads she has already taken. The more I read her, the more I mimic her. Even my internal monologue takes on her syntax. The membranes between my real life and her described life become even more permeable. We fall upon the thorns of life! We bleed—together!

During 8th grade environmental science class, the children are doing an assignment on Natural Disasters. They do not expect my assistance. I reach a point in the book where Batuman and I seem to be experiencing similar romantic struggles. I find this amusing, but only because her situation was a little worse than mine. As I read her account of the soul-crushing situationship she underwent with an unpleasant boy named Ivan, a girl at the desk near me pipes up and asks why I am writing in my book. I am confused, because the book on her desk is full of colorful sticky tabs. She must know what annotation is. What is she playing at?


As I turn to talk, I shift some papers over in a way I hope is teacher-ly. I have inappropriately appropriated the teacher’s desk with my belongings, including my cell phone, which lies garishly face-up. I am rubbing my rights in the kids’ faces, while their cell phones are all locked away in strange pouches. These pouches seem to have a strong magnet which can only be opened, supposedly, with a specific tool. They are weird. They remind me of the TJ Maxx clothing tags clipped on anything over $30, which turn into a real nightmare if the cashier forgets to remove them. The last time I substituted, I watched a group of boys stick pencils into both sides of the alien pouch trying to tear the fabric or force the magnet open. It was all very violent. I didn’t put a stop to it because I didn’t understand what was going on. Then again, I probably wouldn’t have put a stop to it even if I had.

This is all to say, I’m not cut out for teaching. Who am I to tell these children what they should do? I hardly know what I should do. I have no idea if my education was proper — how should I know what would be a proper way to educate them?


The copy of Either/Or is one I hurriedly ‘borrowed’ from The Advocate’s bookshelf. Only after taking it and beginning to write inside it, did I realize it might have come from someone’s private collection, stored for the summer and may not have been free for the taking. I am in limbo — someday, the book’s rightful owner will search for the copy. I’ll have to fess up.


As it turns out, the girl is confused why I am annotating if I am presumably on summer vacation and thus not expected to be doing homework. I tell her I am reading this book for fun. I tell her annotating is fun!


It feels excessive to explain that my annotation is proof I have been here. How bad hikers carve their initials on rocks and trees. The margins are the cave wall, which I guess implies I am a cave man. Gaze upon my exclamation mark! My crooked smiley face! Yes, I came and saw and conquered everything in the book so deeply as to develop a witty comment or better yet, a real evaluative thought. I’ve succeeded in talking about what is being talked about.


Then the bell rings, and we move on. I get a similar batch of kids, who all look the same and have similar temperaments. When you’ve met one 8th grader, you’ve met most of them. They’re in a stage of their life where they haven’t developed distinct personalities yet, but seem to have a vague sense that they ought to do so soon. If they don’t figure it out by high school, they’ll get left behind by the early bloomers who’ve already got personality figured out and like to flaunt this in the face of the starving masses.


Passing through the halls to my next class, I am strongly discouraged by the walls from vaping, or even considering the possibility of vaping.


The wall decorations of a middle school seem to be a precarious undertaking. They give little instruction on developing personality, though I guess that’s difficult to instruct anyway, especially if you’re a wall decoration. The priorities of the administration are clear from what is taped to the white-washed tile. At this time, it appears to be a split between anti-vaping posters and some mildly motivational catchphrases. The former are definitely student-made, while the latter are a professional sort of production.


The vaping posters are amusing, if not a little sad — especially one which says “please please don’t vape,” with the two pleases on separate lines. This could have been a typo, or a desperate syntactical choice, or an attempt at some mind-teaser, like when one is made to read a sentence that has the word the in it twice, but the joke is that one usually does not notice the the second the.


In the next passing period, I returned to coolly examine the posters on the wall — the way one has to sort of kick a pack of cigarettes on the sidewalk, in case there is something inside, at the same time without being obvious about it. The “please please poster” was the only one with such an emotional subtext. I thought of The Smiths but then realized there’s no way these kids are there yet.


The other posters were more clinical: a series of facts about the dangers of vaping, or what sort of punishment a child might encounter if they were to be caught in the act, etc. I wondered whether a more adult approach might have worked better — the red NO SMOKING signs have an air of maturity that perhaps middle schoolers may wish to be treated with, and one which they might respect. Then again, those signs don’t really work on adults, so it’s naïve to consider they might work on a mind as mulish as that of the modern 8th grader. I imagined that designing anti-vaping posters might have been a class assignment that some of these kids submitted for a grade. I wondered if this assignment had made them more or less likely to vape, in the end.


The roommates of the anti-vaping posters — the motivational ones — were on average an eyesore. They all said things like “Your current situation is not your final destination,” and “The only thing sure about luck is that it will change”. I read them and thought about them in an approving way. At least, these posters seemed determined to give more in-depth advice on the future of the human condition past middle school, which is a valiant effort. They were better than the classic, “You got this!” or “Hang in there!” posters that often featured cats. If I remember middle school correctly, this part of life is insufferable. The concept of a final destination — when one’s current situation is 8th grade — feels inconceivable.


The posters, in general, seemed like the sort of thing that was more inspirational to the adults and those of us pretending to be adults, than the kids themselves. Those kinds of sayings, even like “not everything is a competition,” or “when you change your mind, your mind changes,” are parroted through childhood, but don’t sink in completely until one undergoes the real-life process out of which the lesson is born. After all this learning, one remembers the inspirational quote, and understands why it was so often repeated. This is the time when one is liable to repeat it to younger, less experienced members of society, in a well-meaning hope of sparing them the painful process of  learning the lesson. The learned and the learner remain trapped in this futile cycle that will go on forever. Somehow I like the cycle — it feels classic.


My preset awareness of these lessons, even in this phase of my life, is shallow. I will learn them again and again, forgetting their meaning, undergoing the world’s patient examples, trials and tribulations, practically until I die. They’ll deepen each time with understanding, prove to be more and more true, until there is nothing left to get; until they are gotten. After catching regular salmon after regular salmon, I guess someday one is bound to catch at least one Salmon of Wisdom. Over that time, there are more truths of life one ventures to learn, to be there for, to witness and forget again, to close ones eyes before the lust and rapture of, to roll over on the tongue until they dissolve. I am optimistic to assume that anyone ever gets anything completely. I will continue to be optimistic about this. I like to think that, after speaking with many old people whom I consider intelligent, there are ones who have completely gotten at least some things about life.


The smartest old people are the ones that give little to no advice. They understand that the giving of advice is entirely pointless, and have thus graduated from the cycle. Rather than advice, these sorts of old people allow you to try and scrape up what information you can from what is often a hazy, artificially enhanced, and unreliable historical account of their own lives. They know that all things have to be discovered for oneself— the hearing of the lesson does not constitute the meat of the lesson at all. It is appearance only. One is given the formulas by everyone else, but one must do the endless and horrible work of doing all the proofs of life by hand. The catchphrases on the wall are true, but there are gears and pulleys making them true, which the middle schoolers in the 8th grade math room just have not discovered yet. I can’t teach them anything, really, so I won’t try.


Well, I try a little. I explain to the same girl who asked about my book annotations the difference between a credit card and a debit card. Hopefully she’ll learn this again someday.  She asks if her mother has a credit card. I say I’ve got no idea who her mother is, but it’s possible, if not very likely, that her mother has a credit card. She asks why I don’t have a credit card. I tell her I keep getting this question. I tell her I’m wondering the same thing.


I realize that’s not truthful, so I say I’m worried I’ll forget about it and get into a bad situation. She asks what sort of bad situation that might be, and I explain. I worry I’m not teaching her a great lesson, but then realize this isn’t my job anyway — a fake teacher doesn’t have to do anything but follow the real teacher instructions and make sure the kids don’t kill each other in the classroom or, I guess, worse, begin to vape. I talk to her about debt and loans, while her eyes glaze over and she seems to regret ever asking in the first place. I cannot give her any wisdom, and even if I tried, it would be depressing as hell.


The truth of life past middle school is that we all stay in 8th grade forever, but we do get much better at it. I’m talking about credit scores now. I realize happily that I am teaching her an important lesson: don’t ask people to explain things you don’t actually care to hear, because then you’ll get into a bad situation of having to hear them. I spare her after a brief explanation of mortgages and get back to my book — Batuman is talking about her mother. We are all relieved to have it over with when the final bell rings.

THE HARVARD ADVOCATE
21 South Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
president@theharvardadvocate.com